In late September 1944 Field Marshall B. L. Montgomery, a very bold and talented British commander, led an ambitious offensive whose objective was to force an entry into Germany over Rhine. He aimed to capture a series of bridges with the help of paratroopers, who would have to defend them until the main forces arrived.
Him and Premiere Pro have a few things in common: they are both audacious and tend to overreach. Monty’s boldness and wits won him a few battles, especially during his campaigns in Northern Africa. However, in this case his arrogance went a bit too far. Similarly, Premiere Pro also has its Arnhem moments.
Premiere has always included the current frame in the in/out timeline selection, but until the latest release, it has not bothered me much. CS6 introduced a plethora of new features, which made me change my previous workflow from mouse and keyboard driven to more keyboard oriented, mostly due to the new trimming interface, and the unpredictability of the ripple tool, making the problem more pronounced.
The joys of old
It used to be, that the arrow tool (
Easy and fast. Combine that with a few shortcuts to add default transitions, and it turns out that using mouse and keyboard seems to be the most efficient way to go. The simplicity, ease, and flexibility of the timeline manipulation in Premiere was amazing. And for anyone using this method, opening Final Cut Pro legacy was sometimes pretty annoying. And Avid, especially before MC5? Don’t even get me started…
The mixed bag of the new
Then comes Premiere CS6 with its ability to select edit points, and improved trimming. And suddenly, this old workflow seems less and less viable. The hot zones for edit point selections are pretty wide. One has to be careful not to suddenly click on an edit point, because then the trimming mode will be activated, and ctrl will no longer act in predictable manner, giving you the ripple trim as you’d expect. It will change its behavior based on what is selected, and in general make manipulating timeline with a mouse much less efficient.
It’s understandable then, that I found myself drifting more towards the keyboard-oriented workflow, using trimming mode (
And all would be fine and dandy, were it not for the already mentioned fact, that Premiere marks the currently displayed frame as part of the selection. Which means, that if you position your playhead on the edit with the nicely defined shortcut keys (up and down arrow in my case), and press
This is a bit problematic.
I admit I have seen it before – this has been the standard behavior of Premiere from the beginning – but because I hardly ever used in and out in the timeline, this has not bothered me much. However, when the selection started to become the core of my workflow, I found it terribly annoying, and slowing down my work. When I do any of the following operations, I need to constantly remind myself to go back one frame, to avoid the inclusion of the unwanted material:
- lift and/or extract,
- overlay edits with in/out in the timeline,
- exporting based on the in/out selection.
I enjoy editing in CS6 a lot, but this “feature” literally keeps me up at night. It’s such a basic thing, that even Avid got this one right… When the playhead is positioned on an edit point, the out point is selected as the last frame of the incoming clip.
Why then does Premiere behave like Montgomery and has to go one frame too far? British Field Marshall also wanted to eat more than he could chew, and in the end he had to withdraw. Every time I have to go back a frame, I feel like I’m loosing a battle. Why?
Not one frame back, I say!
Very well said! Here’s hoping that PP CS6.5 fixes this. I agree that the Edit Point Selection introduced in CS6 needs some tuning. I’ve send my Feature Requests to Adobe. Hopefully enough editors do the same to give this problem the attention it needs.
This is the default behavior of FCP 1.0 to FCP 7 and Avid Media Composer since at least version 4. The playhead has a duration of exactly one frame, which can be inspected when you zoom all the way in. In Media Composer, you can press a modifier key to make the playhead snap to the edit at -1 frame. If you want that in Premiere Pro, file a feature request: http://www.adobe.com/go/wish
Thanks for your comment, Kevin. In the trim mode Avid changes this behavior, and marks the outpoint “correctly”, and this is what I miss in Premiere. Feature request is always sent before I write any such editorial